Too Faced Brow Quickie Vs. Benefit Gimme Brow: This or That?

It has been a minute since I've done a This or That, where I compare two similar products in price and perhaps quality, to see if one is better than the other. This isn't necessarily a dupe post (there will be one next week!) since they are pretty close in price. Today I'm comparing Too Faced Brow Quickie Vs. Benefit Gimme Brow.

Too Faced Brow Quickie

  • New product
  • Sephora, ULTA, online 
  • $22
  • .17 oz
  • A 12-hour wear, waterproof, brush-on brow fiber gel to fill in sparse brows.
  • 2 shades
  • larger brush compared to Benefit
Too Faced Brow Quickie
  • New packaging (see comparison to old packaging below)
  • Sephora, Ulta, online
  • $24
  • .1 oz
  • An award-winning, brow-volumizing fiber gel that mimics the look of real hair for fuller-looking brows.
  • 3 shades
  • smallest brush

FYI: This is the new vs old Gimme Brow. The product is the exact same, just the packaging changed.

Benefit Gimme Brow

Swatches of each--Too Faced is on top

Brush size comparison--TF on your left, B on your right

  • Wand--Benefit
  • Firmness--Too Faced, but could get crunchy easier
  • Pigmentation/Thicker--Benefit
  • Wear--same
  • Overall, I am still a Benefit fan--the biggest issue is the brush from TF. It's still too big for me, but it's worth a try if you have larger brows.
Have you tried either of these products?

Extra Elle:


  1. I love the post!! I am not using a brow product at the moment but I can see why the smaller wand is better!
    Dora www.BangsBang.com

  2. I've never tried either of these. I think the smaller wand would work best for me! Thanks for sharing your review!

    Doused In Pink

  3. I prefer a smaller brush for brows too, although I do like the TF packaging a lot, great post! Xx

    AlLittleKiran - Bloglovin

  4. Awesome review! I have yet to try a Benefit product that I didn't love, will definitely have to check out their Gimme Brow <3
    Green Fashionista

  5. I love the Benefit Gimme Brow, it's what I currently use!

    Kendal // Life With Kendal

  6. good comparison! i am a benefit hog through and through and i saw that whole new packaging for brow stuff but i can't get over just using plain old shadow and clear mascara over top to set it. it works well!

    xoxo cheshire kat

  7. I don't like big brushes when it comes to brow mascaras... much harder to get a precise application so I'm liking the sounds of the Benefit one:) Thanks as always for doing these and saving us some $$$!

  8. I've debated the Benefit product but the shades are always too dark for me! May give it another whirl. Have you tried Glossier? I like their brow product!

  9. Great comparison! I love a good brow product but haven't tried either of these.

    Amy Ann
    Straight A Style

  10. I agree that the Benefit brush size is a game changer! I can actually use it without it ending up everywhere...easier to do on the go or really quick!

  11. Smaller brush would definitely give a more natural appearance, which is a must when it comes to the eyebrows!


  12. Neither for me as I am more than happy with Essence Make Me Brow which I plan to repurchase again soon.

    Shireen | Reflection of Sanity

  13. This is a great comparison, Elle. I think I would like the Benefit more too all because of the size of the wand. I feel like I could probably be more accurate with a smaller brush!

    xo, Rachel
    A Blonde's Moment

  14. Brows are the new IT THING aren't they?
    I think I need to give more attention to mine - I get them waxed once every 6 weeks & that's about all the mind I give them.

  15. Both look like they did a good job. I'm trying a few new Benefit products and like how they perform.

    little luxury list formerly Chic 'n Cheap Living

  16. I was so close to picking up the benefit one two weeks ago! I have two open brow products at home and I promised myself I'd use them up before purchasing something else. Looks like I'm going with Benefit!

  17. Oooh, great comparison. I was wondering about the TF product vs. the Gimme Brow (which I have). :)

    Happy Tuesday, lady!

    Le Stylo Rouge

  18. This is a great review! I love Too Faced & Benefit products so it's like picking a favorite child to have to choose between them :)

  19. I have never tried any of these but I do a clear one every now and then. I will have to try the benefit one!

  20. Both of these looks amazing! I have never tried anything on my brows but I have been wanting to!

    <3 Shannon
    Upbeat Soles

  21. So is it sad that I do absolutely nothing to my brows except a little grooming pluck now and then?! I probably should up my game and learn what to do with them lol.

  22. I haven't tried the Too Faced but I like the Benefit. I hear there is a really good dupe for it though...

  23. never heard of either of these, I usually love benefits products.


  24. I don't typically wear brow product, but I think the smaller wand would make it much easier to apply!

  25. I have the Benefit Give Me Brow and I absolutely love it! I really love their new packaging too! It's so pretty!

  26. I was wondering if the Benefit Gimme Brow would be worth checking out so thanks for this review/comparison!

  27. Great post! I think the size of the TF wand would put me off trying it! xx

    Beautylymin| Abercrombie & Fitch First Instinct Giveaway

  28. I haven't try either one of these. I love the Elizabeth mott queen of the fill


  29. I have not tried those yet!

    You have such pretty eyes.

  30. I've never tried any of these yet, but in my collection I got a pencil from Aloette and Loreal version of two faced one. I find the Loreal brow plumper so nice even it's great for your piggy bank too !!

    Katie | https://ktmcgworld.blogspot.ca

  31. I haven't tried either one, but I want to try the Benefit one now!


  32. You have perfect brows. I don't think I've ever said that!

  33. I haven't tried the Too Faced product, but I love the Benefit Gimme Brow. I'm using the Essence Make Me Brow right now and it's a great dupe for the Gimme Brow.

  34. I never use anything on my brows, except from a chapstick sometimes, thanks to your recommendation :) But not always. But now when you compared Too Faced and Benefit, I think I would like to try the Too Faced one because it's waterproof, lasts a good amount of hours and is not so pigmented as Benefit! Always a great review!

  35. I agree the smaller brush is a lot easier to handle. Great review!

  36. Other than getting them waxed regularly, I have to admit that I do nothing otherwise to my brows. Sad! I've never tried either of these but I do think I need to start doing SOMETHING with my brows, ha!

  37. From brow picture I'm also loving benefit more :)

  38. I would pick up the Benefit for sure - my eyebrows are not that big!


I respond to comments via email, so make sure I can respond!
For a faster response, please use Twitter or email: elleseesyou@gmail.com

More ways to keep up with me: Bloglovin, Twitter, Pinterest, Instagram , Youtube or email: elleseesyou@gmail.com

You made my day by visiting! See ya tomorrow :)


All products mentioned are purchased by me unless stated.
All pics, thoughts, etc, are mine unless otherwise noted. Publishing or redistributing any content from this blog is strictly prohibited. Please seek permission first. Thank you.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...